The Stoics and Economic Rationality
Abstract
When it comes to the discussions of ancient economic thought, the Stoics rarely come to the forefront. By and large, the lack of focus on this Hellenistic philosophical school is understandable: there is no evidence of the Stoics writing treatises entitled ‘oikonomikos’ or similar or, in fact, showing any substantial interest in the matters pertaining to wealth management or money acquisition. There is an extant fragment, however, depicting a debate between Diogenes of Babylon and Antipater of Tarsus in which the latter advocates for the moral permissibility of the behaviour that comes very close to exhibiting economic rationality. In this paper, I analyse this passage and, noting its complex transmission history, I argue that it reveals an engagement with various ideas pertaining to the oikonomia genre. Although some of them resemble the contemporary notion of economic rationality, ultimately, the Stoic argument is embedded in ethical debates with the Peripatetics and it concerns moral value rather than the homo economicus style of reasoning about maximizing gains
Downloads
References
Annas, J. (1989), «Cicero on Stoic Moral Philosophy and Private Property», in M. Griffin, J. Barnes (eds.), Philosophia Togata I, Oxford, 151-173.
Annas, J. (1993), The Morality of Happiness, Oxford.
Barney, R. (2003), «A Puzzle in Stoic Ethics», Oxford Studies in Ancient Philosophy 24, 303-340.
Brennan, T. (2005), The Stoic Life: Emotions, Duties, and Fate, Oxford. Bresson, A., Harris, E. (2016), «Aristotle and Foreign Trade», in E. Harris, D. Lewis, M. Woolmer (eds.), The Ancient Greek Economy: Markets, Households and City-States, Cambridge, 41-65.
Čelkytė, A. (2023), «The Medico-Oikonomic Model of Human Nature in Bryson’s Oikonomikos », Phronesis 68, 2, 206-235.
Dyck, A. (1996), A Commentary on Cicero, De Officiis, Ann Arbor. Finley, M. I. (1973), The Ancient Economy, Berkely.
Gill, C. (2023), Learning to Live Naturally: Stoic Ethics and Its Modern Significance, Oxford.
Goulet-Cazé, M.-O. (2003), Les Kynica du stoïcisme , Stuttgart. Helmer, É. (2024), «Debating the Legitimacy of Trade in Xenophon’s Oeconomicus 20, 22- 29», forthcoming.
Helmer, É. (2021), Oikonomia: Philosophie grecque de l’économie, Paris.
Inwood, B. (2022), Later Stoicism 155 BC to AD 200: An Introduction and Collection of Sources in Translation, Cambridge.
Johnstone, S. (1994), «Virtuous Toil, Vicious Work: Xenophon on Aristocratic Style», Classical Philology 89, 3, 219-240.
Leese, M. (2017), «Kapêloi and Economic Rationality in Fourth-Century B.C.E. Athens», Illinois Classical Studies 42, 1, 41-59.
Leese, M. (2021), Making money in ancient Athens, Ann Arbor.
Mayer, E. (2020), «Money Making, “Avarice”, and Elite Strategies of Distinction in the Roman World», in E. Stewart, E. Harris, D. Lewis (eds.), Skilled Labour and Professionalism in Ancient Greece and Rome, Cambridge, 94-126.
Meikle, S. (1995), Aristotle’s Economic Thought, New York-Oxford.
Moreno, A. (2007), Feeding the Democracy the Athenian Grain Supply in the Fifth and Fourth Centuries B.C., Oxford.
Ng, I. L., Tseng, L.-M. (2008), «Learning to be Sociable: The Evolution of Homo Economicus», The American Journal of Economics and Sociology 67, 2, 265-286.
Ober, J. (2022), Greeks and the Rational: The Discovery of Practical Reason, Berkeley
Pohlenz, M. (1965), «Cicero, de officiis III», in Kleine Schriften , I, Hildesheim, 253-291; originally in Nachrichten von der königlichen Gesellschaft der Wissenschaften zu Göttingen, philologische-historische Klasse I 1 (1934), 1-40.
Rowe, C. (2002), «The Politeiai of Zeno and Plato», in T. Scaltsas, A.S. Mason (eds.), The Philosophy of Zeno, Cyprus, 291-308.
Schofield, M. (2002), «“Impossible Hypotheses”: Was Zeno’s Republic Utopian?», in T. Scaltsas, A.S. Mason (eds.), The Philosophy of Zeno, Cyprus, 309-324.
Schofield, M. (2006), «Morality and the Law: The Case of Diogenes of Babylon», Philosophical Inquiry 28, 1-2, 179-202.
Schumpeter, J.A. (1954), History of Economic Analysis, London.
Sellars, J. (2007), «Stoic Cosmopolitanism and Zeno’s Republic », History of Political Thought 28, 1, 1-29.
Staveren, I. van. (2001), The values of economics: an Aristotelian perspective, London.
Striker, G. (1996a), «Following Nature: A study in Stoic Ethics», in Essays on Hellenistic Epistemology and Ethics, Cambridge, 221-280.
Striker, G. (1996b), «Antipater, or the Art of Living», in Essays on Hellenistic Epistemology and Ethics, Cambridge, 298-315.
Thesleff, H. (1961), An Introduction to the Pythagorean Writings of the Hellenistic Period , Åbo.
Tsouna, V. (2013), Philodemus “On Property Management”, Williston.
Urbina, D.A., Ruiz-Villaverde, A. (2019), «A Critical Review of Homo Economicus from Five Approaches: A Critical Review of Homo Economicus», American Journal of Economics and Sociology 78, 1, 63-93.
White, S. (2010), «Stoic selection: Objects, Actions, and Agents», in A. Nightingale, D. Sedley (eds.), Ancient Models of Mind: Studies in Human and Divine Rationality, Cambridge, 110-129.
Woolmer, M. (2016), «Forging Links between Regions: Trade Policy in Classical Athens», in E. Harris, D. Lewis, M. Woolmer (eds.), The Ancient Greek Economy: Markets, Households and City-States, Cambridge, 66-89.
Se permite que los autores de los artículos y de las discusiones publicados en la revista los reproduzcan en otros sitios siempre y cuando se haga mención de que han sido previamente publicados en ΠΗΓΗ/FONS.
Funding data
-
Nederlandse Organisatie voor Wetenschappelijk Onderzoek
Grant numbers NWO VI.Vidi.191.205)
